Friday, December 25, 2009

A good thing comes to an end...

I had to say goodbye to my parents yesterday evening after a glorious two-week holiday. It was terrible to part ways, perhaps made more difficult because of the wonderful time we had together. I experienced South Africa in many new ways while they were here, some of which are shared below. Any of you reading this blog must consider vacationing in South Africa—it really is a world-class destination offering a diverse array of rich experiences. Even my notoriously difficult-to-please father called it his favorite ever vacation destination!

After our three days in the wine lands of Stellenbosch and Franschhoek—during which we ate and drank ourselves into a near coma—we made our way to the town of Rawsonville, ostensibly as our departure point for a daylong safari we had scheduled for the 21st of December. I am sometimes reminded of the fact that I am descended from a long line of peasants, and really am one myself, and my experience of Rawsonville affirmed this again given that it was my favorite part of the whole trip. The town is a very sleepy little place in the mountain foothills, and our guest house was situated in an agricultural valley. We stayed on a working wine farm once owned by the governor of the Western Cape province. The main home was a stunning Dutch Cape home built several hundred years ago and we stayed in an oh-so-charming converted staff cottage with a huge veranda overlooking the vineyards, mountains, and sunsets. This place put me into such a state of relaxation that I could hardly be bothered to eat meals (I was not, however, challenged in my wine consumption).

But this wasn’t even the best part of the place! A ten minute walk into the hills behind the house led to the most picturesque and Eden-like place I’ve ever been: a water fall cascading into a deep, clear, and warm rock pool. I spent every possible moment swimming in this slice of paradise, and when I wasn’t there I was thinking about being there.

As I said, our purpose for visiting Rawsonville was a safari at the Aquila Game Reserve. What a treat! We were met by a ranger with champagne in hand upon arrival, were treated to indulgent meals the whole day through, had champagne breaks DURING the safari, and swam in a stunning pool when finished. Oh, but we were there to see the animals… We saw elephants, rhinos, giraffes, lions, cheetahs, hippos, buffalo, zebras, springbok, and lions, among others. These creatures really are magnificent and the whole experience was one of those once-in-a-lifetime treats that I’ll treasure forever.

After Rawsonville and the safari, our final destination was a little village south of Cape Town called Simons Town. This place is known principally for the penguins that hang out at a little beach in the area called Boulders Beach. It is also the closest infrastructure to Cape Point, the point at the confluence of the Indian and Atlantic Oceans. While in Simons Town we chilled with the penguins, explored Cape Point and the Cape of Good Hope, ate lots of good food, and mostly relaxed as a family over the Christmas holiday. We had an amazing Cuban dinner for Christmas Eve and then celebrated the actual holiday at the Khans’ with some of their friends and family.

On the whole, I could not ask for a more successful trip. I am beat from all the travels and taking some time for recovery, but will be rested and able to apply fresh eyes and intellect to my project when I pick it up again early in the New Year.

I hope each of you has enjoyed the holiday season to this point and I wish you only the best in 2010.

Cheers,
Todd

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

The Death of a Dubious Figure

Sorry folks, no photos with this one...I'll summarize the rest of my holiday vacation in the next few days and provide lots of photos there.

There was a significant death in South Africa this past week: the former Minister of Health, Manto Tshabala-Msimang died of liver failure. To say that she was a controversial character is an understatement. That’s like stating the obvious fact that George Bush was a controversial president. Tshabala-Msimang and former President Mbeki are the architects behind the delay in AIDS treatment for millions of South Africans. She never, ever would have assented to the provision of therapy if she had not been publicly flogged to such a degree that she relented and consorted with Mbeki to provide a sort of anemic therapy regime. The public response to her death has been anything but mournful. Rather, people feel that a bit of karmic intentionality may have been at work. She was on her second liver already, in line for a third when she died, and gained heaps of unwanted attention when she was exposed as demanding alcohol while still in the hospital after her first transplant.

Tshabala-Msimang was frequently referred to as Dr. Beetroot because she suggested that people take beetroot as an alternative to biomedical treatments for AIDS. The extent to which she believed the information she disseminated versus simply towing the line for Thabo Mbeki will likely forever remain a mystery. But what is clear is that she leaves a legacy of hugely negative proportions. At her funeral this week, President Zuma claimed she was an unsung hero of the anti-Apartheid struggle, which she may indeed be true, but her legacy will not surround such accomplishments.

Perhaps unfortunately, her work as a freedom fighter in exile has been obscured by the policies for which she advocated for eight years as Minister of Health in South Africa. She spoke fluent Russian, having received her medical training in Russia (which is an interesting story in itself: Russia trained legions of South Africans under the Communist regime as a sort of alliance amongst nations persecuted by the West (black and colored South Africa being perceived as persecuted by the West under the Apartheid system)). Her history with the ANC and the fight for liberation and democracy was a respectable one, but over the course of the last eight years she was demonized and vilified in the public eye. While I am loathe to celebrate the suffering or passing of human beings, and as someone earning an intellectual degree I feel I should not weigh in emotionally on this cause, I think there is just cause on both sides or the reactionary divide.

She was vilified, perhaps unfairly, for her role in delaying treatment for millions of South Africans living with HIV. She may have supported these policies or she may simply have supported the President and liked having a job. The Lancet, a British medical journal, recently incisively argued that this delay cost the lives of 330,000 South Africans. So you be the judge on that one. Alternatively, there are a lot of reasons to represent the perspective she did, namely that Western biomedicine is a WESTERN phenomenon, and black South Africans know to be deeply distrustful of anything Western, for it was the Western world, after all, that allowed the perpetuation of the Apartheid system for decades. And the introduction of Western biomedicine in South Africa to black South Africans was modeled along the lines of Nazi Germany, where the real goal was an extermination campaign, complete with horrific human experiments of sickening design.

At the end of the day I’m just very curious. Why did she really say what she did and enact such policies? Did she really believe that eating garlic and lemon could cure HIV? Did she really believe that the treatment so pervasive in the rest of the world was unsuited for her people? How could she witness mass death with such ambivalence? Or did she just want to make policies without white Westerners interfering with her work? I had hoped I or someone else might someday find the answers to these questions, through her own words, but her passing means that opportunity is now lost.

At the end of the day, I’m not a fan—far from it. She should have known better and she let allegiance to a party and a President cloud her judgment. But I DO reserve most of my judgment because I can’t creep around in the recesses of her brain, nor can I understand how Apartheid impacted her psyche. That’s my take, which is considerably less partial than the discourses circulating in South African currently.

Stay well,
Todd

Saturday, December 19, 2009

A Cape Christmas

I must admit that it does not much feel like Christmastime right now. I am generally familiar with cold, wet, and snow during the holiday season, not the longest and most beautiful days of the year that we’re currently experiencing in South Africa. I’ve realized here that I associate Christmas with the cozy feeling of being indoors or near a fire or trying at all costs to avoid inclement weather. Not that I’m complaining about my current circumstances! I know I’m really settled here because it rained briefly (like for perhaps 10 minutes) the other day and I was incensed by this interruption of my day.

My parents have been in South Africa since last Sunday (Paul is in Alaska, crazy bird that he is); we spent four days in Cape Town, seeing all the sites (Table Mountain Cable Car, Robben Island, a concert at the botanical garden, the Victoria & Albert Waterfront, a township tour with my right-hand man Sipho, wine tasting, and lots of great meals out with the Khans). We’re now in the wine lands where we’ve been eating world-class meals and tasting amazing (and very inexpensive) wine. We’ve been exploring in the mornings and chilling poolside in the afternoons. It really does feel like a holiday for me as well and having a car means we are very mobile and can explore as we wish. Last night we dined with the Khans at a sort of ‘African experience’ place called Moyo at the Spier Wine Estate. While I was slightly horrified to have any association with such a place, the food and entertainment was top notch (the face painting, however, took the experience to a whole new level of kitsch).

While the trip has been overwhelmingly posh and allowed us to pursue every possible hedonistic pleasure, I have also endeavored to share with my Mom and Dad the many dimensions of South Africa. We’ve had long chats with the domestic staff at the Khans’ home and took a version of a township tour with which I was comfortable. Sipho took us to his home and showed us around his community and some other townships. We also saw the circumcision tents on the outskirts of the city, which was a unique—and rather odd—experience. The tour was a real eye-opener for my parents, but I was impressed how they strived to understand and analyze the experience. Sipho is a very thoughtful guy who knows the city inside and out, so he was the perfect guide.

Tomorrow we’re off to the Aquilla game reserve for a few days and then we’ll come back to Cape Town for Christmas with the Khans. Lately I have come to appreciate the incredible beauty, in all its forms, of this amazing country. While I generally have a rather dour perspective about South Africa’s future, that doesn’t overshadow the tremendous progress that has been made and the incredible richness it has to offer.

All good wishes this holiday season.

Much love,
Todd

Monday, December 14, 2009

The Help

South Africa is a place of extensive and widening inequality. As I’ve noted previously, the country has a robust informal economy, the creativity and entrepreneurship of which never ceases to amaze me. Most people of even modest means have domestic workers in their homes to cook, clean, garden, or look after their children. Even in my household of students, we employ two women—Nokulungu and Naquanda—who clean on Tuesdays and Thursdays, respectively. The Khans have two housekeepers and two gardeners who work full-time at their home. I am carefully attentive to these people because it is through them that I learn a great deal about this country and its social milieu.

For instance, the gardeners at the Khans’ house are named Simba and Simon. They are cousins from Zimbabwe. Simba’s wife Joyce has actually just arrived from Zimbabwe and she now works in the house as well. Simba and Joyce have left their three small children behind in the hands of Joyce’s mother. Simon’s wife is also a domestic worker here in Cape Town and they have two kids in rural Zimbabwe as well. I cannot imagine the anguish of leaving one’s children behind for a year at a time, but such are the choices made by many across sub-Saharan Africa who migrate to South Africa in search of opportunities or a meager livelihood; to witness the condition of these people as they offload from busses each day is an experience that will pull at anyone’s heartstrings. Once here, migrants hope to find employment and then send remittances home in an effort to care for family members left behind.

One issues of social and political salience in South Africa is the use of such migrant laborers at all because the country has an unemployment rate in the 30-45% range according to most estimates. Proponents of migration, typically those associated with industry, claim that migrant labor is needed to support their businesses, while opponents charge that opportunities are being poached from South Africans. Since I’ve been here a huge scandal has erupted over the use of Zimbabwean workers in the agricultural sector in the Western Cape (where Cape Town is located). It has come to light that some farmers are paying people the equivalent of $8-$10 per week, significantly below the minimum wage, and insultingly below any sort of measure of livability. The real tragedy from my perspective is that the story translated into the hounding and persecution of the Zimbabweans, who are obviously desperate if they are willing to work for those salaries, by other residents of the area—their homes were torched by other poor South Africans, who literally pushed the Zimbabweans out of their communities in witch hunt-style acts of persecution. Currently, the displaced persons are living in a Red Cross-sponsored camp until a decision is to made as to their futures.

But this isn’t the only story. The Khans have employed a housekeeper named Talita for the past six years. She is a South African with two young children, Zimi and Zenathi; the kids occasionally spend time at the house because the Khans adore them. I must admit that I have fallen for Talita in a very big way. She is warm, funny, acerbic, and embraced me from the day I arrived. She teaches me a lot about South Africa and is a person I respect for her resilience and good nature, even though she returns home to a shack each night and will never have a career beyond domestic service. I think what I like more is that she doesn’t mince words, and has a way of telling it like it is but expressing caring at the same time. Talita has big dreams for her kids, and the Khans have committed to helping her achieve a brighter future for them. She and the kids are pictured here. I haven’t taken pictures of Simon, Simba, or Joyce yet because I can’t quite find a context to do so. The picture of Talita and her family was taken on a day we took them to a local amusement park for the day.

I recently read Kathryn Stockett’s new book The Help, the inspiration for the title of this post; I enjoyed it very much, and would recommend it to anyone interested in an excellent work of fiction that digs below the surface of the domestic labor economy in the American south. While it was an outsider’s story written by a white woman, I think it did richly capture the fraught relationship and vulnerability experienced by both the patron and the charge in these relationships, though obviously the risk is much greater for the domestic worker. Such is what I find so compelling here in South Africa: there is a mutual reliance in these dynamics that generally remains unspoken (for service of a very intimate kind on one end and an income on the other). Over the course of a lifetime, people engaged in these relationships can grow very close, yet never fully trust one-another and go to bed at night in the most disparate of worlds.

One consequence of the way the post-Apartheid political and economic restructuring has been handled in South Africa is that some people have become very, very rich while the ranks of the poor have swelled. It has been incisively argued, and I would agree, that the use of poor laborers to support this system is what leads to aggrieved acts of violence for which this country is so well-known—people are exposed all day everyday to the riches they can never expect for themselves, ultimately reaching a breaking point as they toil harder each year for a very meager slice of the pie (some additional pictures of the community of Deflt, a truly bleak place, are posted here; I took them earlier this week at a CHMT Open Day). Personally, it’s difficult for me to image work more grinding than that of domestic labor, save very physical labor associated with industries like construction. Until South Africa addresses this level of inequality, the shockingly high rates of violence and crime will be sustained. Most people are cognizant of this fact, but are often unwilling to make personal sacrifices to achieve this alternative world.

Postings like this are interesting to write—I’m often unsure of my agenda, but I try to tell what I find to be important stories, especially for those of us concerned with the very vulnerable in this world. My parents arrive in South Africa yesterday for two weeks, so hopefully upcoming posts will be of smiling faces doing exciting things!

Happy holidays to you all!

Todd

Monday, December 7, 2009

HIV & Social Change

Being a young kid when HIV first emerged on the global scene, I never witnessed how it changed attitudes, behaviors, practices, prejudices, etc., and only abstractly understood how it impacted various communities. After the past two months of research, I am beginning to understand how HIV really did—and continues to—change the world in a very dramatic way. For all the talk about cultural sensitivity and the very real desires to work within myriad knowledge systems, cultures, and beliefs, there is simply no denying that HIV requires that everyone drastically modify their behavior in sub-Saharan Africa. To the extent that the disease continues to burgeon in South Africa, I would argue it is because of a failure to change practices—or, to state the challenge with more finesse, to change systems and societies in such a way that allows people to make safe, healthy, and informed choices. This isn’t about people not listening or Africans being immune to Western biomedical teachings; rather, it is about context of poverty and deprivation as the key factors shaping disease exposure.

I will admit to often finding myself simply wanting to shake people and shout, “Are you listening? What don’t you understand?” I’m not one to act rashly, which is a good thing considering that such behaviors are part of the problem, rather than the solution. But nonetheless I’ve been confronted with a very perplexing issue: why, when people know how HIV is transmitted and how to keep themselves healthy, do they engage in practices that put them at great risk? After all, South Africa has expended massive resources on prevention, and has now made a significant investment in treatment. The answer to the above questions is actually a simple one from my perspective—until the very conditions of life (both material and social) are modified such that people value their own lives and wish to see the future, they will have no reason to abstain from high-risk practices. Grinding poverty creates conditions that those of us outside this for of marginality cannot really understand, and subsequently should not judge. And even for those in this context who do have a sense of self-worth and an understanding of the greater complexities in this world, choice is often the key factor missing from the decision-making apparatus for people, particularly women.

A very, very common practice in South Africa is for women to engage in concurrent sexual partnerships as a means of feeding and otherwise caring for themselves and their children. It is the most masculine behavior for men to have multiple partners, something to applaud and envy, but for women this is a deeply shameful act—which is distressing given that as South African women grow increasingly poorer, they are forced to succumb to the proclivities of men with increasing frequency. When the choice is a hungry child or unprotected sex in exchange for food, most mothers will chose the latter without question. Poverty begets seemingly bad choices, but the fact is that most people engaging in high-risk behaviors do so in a very calculated and rational way. And to them we owe more than harsh judgment and exported abstinence only campaigns.

HIV does not allow for values to change slowly and its consequences cannot simply be absorbed by societies as the other impacts of unprotected sex might (pregnancy, other STIs). To acquire HIV, while no longer representing imminent death, profoundly changes a person’s life. It is no longer business as usual. There are plenty of diseases and conditions rife in the world that also expose social injustices (among them tuberculosis, malaria, and even chronic gastrointestinal conditions), but what makes HIV unique is the way it exposes with great precision the very nature of how our societies operate. And, ultimately, this is why I find it such a fascinating disease to study—the virus as a biological phenomenon is not my interest, but the conditions that allow it to flourish are.

Certain practices and ways of being must cease to exist with HIV—no matter who or where you are—which I believe is part of the challenge in really preventing and treating AIDS in South Africa. Certain practices, like using the same blade to circumcise multiple men at once or women who are HIV+ insisting on breastfeeding their children must cease to happen for society to reproduce itself. There are ways to integrate HIV knowledge into existing knowledge systems, but also the required changes in behavior and practice mean that whole new ways of knowing must be developed. While I knew this abstractly before coming to South Africa a couple months ago, I know understand it in a very tangible way. My understanding of each of the above topics has been refined through my experiences with the Community Health Media Trust, an organization composed of extraordinary human beings, all of whom are doing their part to create a healthier South Africa.

Mostly, I’m sharing my long-time-in-coming odyssey to a place of non-judgment and deeper understanding—and I hope I’ve made a good case for a rich and empathetic approach to understanding health and personal agency in this world. Throughout this post are images of my friends at the Community Health Media Trust, which whom I travel around the Western Cape sharing information about HIV and AIDS. They host weekly events called Open Days, where they bombard a different community with information about HIV/AIDS via a massive PA system—basically they draw a crowd by getting a massive block party going and then force people to listen to their messages. It’s a really novel approach that works very well. These images will also show how the majority of South Africans live, in conditions of abject poverty.

I hope each of you is well and is enjoying the holiday season!

All good wishes,
Todd