
Being a young kid when HIV first emerged on the global scene, I never witnessed how it changed attitudes, behaviors, practices, prejudices, etc., and only abstractly understood how it impacted various communities. After the past two months of research, I am beginning to understand how HIV really did—and continues to—change the world in a very dramatic way. For all the talk about cultural sensitivity and the very real desires to work within myriad knowledge systems, cultures, and beliefs, there is simply no denying that HIV requires that everyone drastically modify their behavior in sub-Saharan Africa. To the extent that the disease continues to burgeon in South Africa, I would argue it is because of a failure to change practices—or, to state the challenge with more finesse, to change systems and societies in such a way that allows people to make safe, healthy, and informed choices. This isn’t about people not listening or Africans being immune to Western biomedical teachings; rather, it is about context of poverty and deprivation as the key factors shaping disease exposure.
I will admit to often finding myself simply wanting to shake people and shout, “Are you listening? What don’t you understand?” I’m not one to act rashly, which is a good thing considering that such behaviors are part of the problem, rather than the solution. But nonetheless I’ve been confronted with a very perplexing issue: why, when people know how HIV is transmitted and how to keep themselves healthy, do they engage in practices that put them at great risk? After all, South Africa has expended massive resources on prevention, and has now made a significant investment in treatment.

The answer to the above questions is actually a simple one from my perspective—until the very conditions of life (both material and social) are modified such that people value their own lives and wish to see the future, they will have no reason to abstain from high-risk practices. Grinding poverty creates conditions that those of us outside this for of marginality cannot really understand, and subsequently should not judge. And even for those in this context who do have a sense of self-worth and an understanding of the greater complexities in this world, choice is often the key factor missing from the decision-making apparatus for people, particularly women.
A very, very common practice in South Africa is for women to engage in concurrent sexual partnerships as a means of feeding and otherwise caring for themselves and their children. It is the most masculine behavior for men to have multiple partners, something to applaud and envy, but for women this is a deeply shameful act—which is distressing given that as South African women grow increasingly poorer, they are forced to succumb to the proclivities of men with increasing frequency.

When the choice is a hungry child or unprotected sex in exchange for food, most mothers will chose the latter without question. Poverty begets seemingly bad choices, but the fact is that most people engaging in high-risk behaviors do so in a very calculated and rational way. And to them we owe more than harsh judgment and exported abstinence only campaigns.
HIV does not allow for values to change slowly and its consequences cannot simply be absorbed by societies as the other impacts of unprotected sex might (pregnancy, other STIs).

To acquire HIV, while no longer representing imminent death, profoundly changes a person’s life. It is no longer business as usual. There are plenty of diseases and conditions rife in the world that also expose social injustices (among them tuberculosis, malaria, and even chronic gastrointestinal conditions), but what makes HIV unique is the way it exposes with great precision the very nature of how our societies operate. And, ultimately, this is why I find it such a fascinating disease to study—the virus as a biological phenomenon is not my interest, but the conditions that allow it to flourish are.
Certain practices and ways of being must cease to exist with HIV—no matter who or where you are—which I believe is part of the challenge in really preventing and treating AIDS in South Africa.

Certain practices, like using the same blade to circumcise multiple men at once or women who are HIV+ insisting on breastfeeding their children must cease to happen for society to reproduce itself. There are ways to integrate HIV knowledge into existing knowledge systems, but also the required changes in behavior and practice mean that whole new ways of knowing must be developed. While I knew this abstractly before coming to South Africa a couple months ago, I know understand it in a very tangible way. My understanding of each of the above topics has been refined through my experiences with the Community Health Media Trust, an organization composed of extraordinary human beings, all of whom are doing their part to create a healthier South Africa.
Mostly, I’m sharing my long-time-in-coming odyssey to a place of non-judgment and deeper understanding—and I hope I’ve made a good case for a rich and empathetic approach to understanding health and personal agency in this world. Throughout this post are images of my friends at the Community Health Media Trust, which whom I travel around the Western Cape sharing information about HIV and AIDS.

They host weekly events called Open Days, where they bombard a different community with information about HIV/AIDS via a massive PA system—basically they draw a crowd by getting a massive block party going and then force people to listen to their messages. It’s a really novel approach that works very well. These images will also show how the majority of South Africans live, in conditions of abject poverty.
I hope each of you is well and is enjoying the holiday season!
All good wishes,
Todd