Friday, November 13, 2009

Health & Health Care in Cape Town



The past week has been an illuminating and rich time of exploration and learning. I finally made it out to several community health clinics located in Cape Town’s sprawling townships. My project advanced almost exponentially over the past week in terms of data gathering, but also because I now feel that I ‘get it’ in a way I couldn’t until actually visiting the clinics. And through this process of learning and listening, I feel emotionally depleted by the stories I’ve heard, the conditions I’ve witnessed, and the knowledge that South Africa has a very, very long way to go before reversing trends in HIV prevalence and incidence.

Principally, my goal at the community health clinics is to interview Treatment Literacy Practitioners (TLPs). These young men and women act as ancillary staff members to the clinical personnel. Their task is to educate everyone who comes through the door about HIV by making waiting rooms into impromptu classrooms; they also provide much more intensive and personalized education to those diagnosed with HIV. Because these are antenatal clinics, and because nationally almost 40% of women attending antenatal clinics test positive for HIV, their work is a vital supplement to existing (and massively overstretched) clinical caregiving.

The rates of HIV in this country are incomprehensibly high. Roughly one in nine South Africans are HIV positive, but this translates in really horrifying ways: for instance, half of the country’s fifteen year olds will die from HIV. And while the rates are seemingly ridiculously high, spending time in these clinics they seem like an underestimate. Everyone has siblings, cousins, children, etc. who are HIV+. And given a culture of secrecy around the disease, it is quite possible that rates are higher than officially reported (this is not just my hypothesis...).

One pleasant surprise was the condition of the clinics. While sparse, many are modern buildings that can accommodate large numbers of people. They are generally well-stocked with medicines and have the infrastructure to meet the community’s needs. Even where the buildings are dilapidated, I have come to realize that the physical condition of a place cannot be seen as a proxy for the services rendered. The first picture in this post is of the Nolungile Clinic in the Khayelitsha township. Khayelitsha is the poorest township in Cape Town, being the landing point for work- or asylum-seeking for immigrants from all over the continent—and yet the clinic is a model space. The other picture of the very tired-looking building is in one of the oldest townships, Langa. Included throughout this post are other photos of township living conditions.

The important caveat is that while the infrastructure may exist, there are systemic funding problems and massive human resource shortages in South Africa. The national health system currently has 40,000 vacant clinical positions posted. In essence, there are simply not enough trained professionals, a fact compounded by attrition of the health care force due to HIV. Subsequently, a person who wants to obtain antiretroviral therapy must arrive at the clinic between 4:30 and 6:00 in the morning for the clinic to open at 8:00. Nurses will only take a certain number of patients each day, so if you are not amongst the early arrivals, you will not be seen and subsequently not dispensed your medication.
People who arrive at 4:30 in the morning are fortunate to make it out the door by noon. As the numbers of people enrolled in treatment increases, this problem is being exacerbated to the point of being untenable. The knock-on effect is to overwork all staff members, poisoning their attitudes, and further undermining the system.

There is much, much, much more to the story, particularly surrounding the vulnerability of women in South African society, poverty, and issues of stigma and violence, but I will use space at a later date to cover these topics. While I am of course inspired by the leadership and compassion of people working in these clinics, this was a tough week in which to end on a positive note, especially because I sat in on a support groups session of HIV+ mothers and their HIV+ babies today. Knowing that poverty and gendered power imbalances—and ultimately the history of apartheid—created conditions that allow (encourage even) such outcomes leaves one feeling like a small fish in a very large and unjust sea. But onward I go…

I’ll keep writing about health care in the future and promise to find a lighter topic for the next post!

Best wishes,
Todd

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Cape Town

First up, some promised photos of me with my adopted families here in Cape Town. The first is of me with my housemates (from left: Rein (Dutch), Kolade (Nigerian), and Emma (South African)) on Friday night when we hosted a party. The second is of the Khans and I (Declan next to me and then Felicity and Blum opposite) at the end of my birthday dinner. All are wonderful people with whom I’m privileged to share this experience. Oh, and I’ve included a photograph of the flower the Khan’s housekeeper, Talita, gave me for my birthday because it is the most stunning flower I’ve ever seen—and it self preserves!

But now to the more interesting stuff… My friend Jean requested that I describe Cape Town from the vantage point of the city’s street markets, which I thought was an excellent idea. Like any other city, Cape Town has its glamorous quarters and a darker side that reflects the inequities rampant in the country. In essence, Cape Town is everything: violent, endearing, pulsating, energetic, challenging, beautiful, ugly, etc. etc. Like the whole of sub-Saharan Africa, the city has a massive informal economy of street vendors, domestic workers, craftspeople, taxi drivers, etc. What is difficult to convey to those who have not visited is the extent of this informal economy and the creativity it generates—nowhere is the entrepreneurial spirit more alive than here in South Africa. At any major intersection, for instance, there will be people selling newspapers in the streets and often someone selling each of the following: crafts, flowers, joke pamphlets, and window washing, to name a few.

As for the street market experience, it just depends where you look, where you live, and who you are. As such, the street market experience is a variable one, but basically one can acquire anything on the street: music, clothes, food, sunglasses, crafts, sunscreen, hair braids, calling cards, animals, etc. What is perhaps unique about Cape Town is that the city-center markets are within a stone’s throw of some of the poshest stores in the world, so there are juxtapositions at every turn. Mainly when navigating these markets I am on sensory overload, but also feel like this is the only way to get a pulse on the denizens that descend on Cape Town from the townships each day. I particularly love a spice market near the train station where women operate spice stalls, typically for curries. I’ve also been getting friendly with some of the vendors along my running path who make amazing beaded animals for sale to passing tourists—through them I’ve come to realize that income generated this way is a poverty income for sure, and that most informal vendors are actually immigrants from other Southern African countries, namely Zimbabwe.

Included are some photos of the local markets; they unfortunately do not do the experience justice but you can get a sense of the products available and the look of the street markets.

One of the disappointing facts I learned upon arrival in Cape Town last year is that my favorite street market, the Green Point Market, was leveled to make way for the new World Cup stadium. The market formerly had a choice piece of waterfront real estate—which is now dominated by a new stadium. Such is the push and pull of the informal economy and new development (with the latter always winning). What was formerly a huge market has never been re-established in Cape Town. On the flipside, I do like that the huge square outside of the parliamentary building in Cape Town is one giant street market (one of the photos shows it in set-up mode in the early morning). One of my favorite experiences when traveling is to rise early and watch the vendors set up their stands—I love this sleepy time and the transformation that occurs as the city comes to life. Such is what I did last week one morning; a couple of these photos are from that time.

I keep waiting to write about health care because I want some good photos, which I expect to get this week.

I hope each of you is well!

All good wishes,
T

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

South African English

While nearly all Cape Townians speak English, it is not my English, especially when it comes to vocabulary. I honestly find myself constantly confused and much can get lost in translation. We’re not talking about simple stuff like cilantro being coriander or Jelly being Jell-o. These are genuine language barrier differences. In part this is because Afrikaans, the Dutch-derived language spoken by most white and mixed race South Africans, bleeds into English in unique and often amusing ways. I thought I might share some of my favorite words/phrases in the everyday English lexicon:

Bucky= pickup truck
Mother City= Cape Town
Sorry!= to get someone’s attention (i.e. “Excuse me…”)
Dop= alcoholic drink
Howzit?= How are you?
Izzit?= Is that right?
Hectic= fantastic
Eina!= Ouch!
Robot= traffic light
Sundowner= cocktail enjoyed at sunset
China= male friend
Missioning= toiling on a task all day
Shame!= What a pity!
Now= not now, but soon (this one takes some getting used to)
Now-now= immediately
Minister of Finance= sugar daddy

And, my personal favorite…

Crosstitue= a politician who changes parties by crossing the floor of parliament


I had another indulgent weekend care of the Khans. I’ve come to refer to my Obz house as the city house and the Khan’s Hunter’s Moon estate as my country manor; I love both, but latter is considerably more posh than the former. We went to what was casually referred to as an afternoon tea at a neighbor’s house Saturday afternoon. Naturally, I’m expecting a cup of tea and perhaps a biscuit. Well, we arrive and there is a) lunch service for 100 on the lawn, b) a live Abba performance on a stage framing the mountain view, and c) more wide-brimmed hats than I have ever seen in my entire life. There were several other inspiring performances as we watched the sun descend in the sky, making for an out-of-this world evening. As you can tell, I’m living well in Cape Town...


Sunday was the real treat of the week however. The Khans hosted a dozen kids from a township at their house for an afternoon garden party. There are dozens of newly born ducklings and chicks on the grounds right now, so we took the kids to see the various foul, then had a lunch and pool party. The kids were a delight and were very grateful for the whole experience (a couple photos are included). Many were in their teens but not in school for various reasons and most live in informal settlements in the city. The experience was fun, but also puts into stark relief the disparities that exist in Cape Town, where young children often don’t have access to health care, homes, schools, family support, etc. A really great moment came when the connection was made that Blum attended the same primary school as these kids many years ago; I think it was jarring for the kids to see someone who has achieved such success arising from their very circumstances, but the dialogue that ensued was really a productive one. I was really impressed by how much the kids looked after each other and particularly impressed by their Sunday school teacher, Mavis, who coordinated the outing. She’s one of those everyday hero volunteers who dedicates herself to serving the forgotten youth of this country. She (standing in black) and Felicity (standing in white) are pictured here with the kids.


There’s the update! Next up: health care and I’ll try to capture, from the streets, this enigma that is Cape Town. I also have a photo of me and the Khans at dinner the other night that I’ll post once I download it off my camera. Also, because nearly everyone keeps requesting photos of my house, included are a few--including my favorite feature, the outdoor shower!

T

Friday, October 30, 2009

Apartheid

Mercifully, a couple of you (named Suzanne and Beth) requested that I cover a few topics, and, as it happens, things are getting interesting on their own… I’ll cover Apartheid here (well, as best a privileged outsider can) and then touch on health in the next few days.

As I often do, I presumed that readers know what Apartheid is and how it continues to challenge the prospects for a prosperous democracy in South Africa. Apartheid literally means apartness or separateness and was officially codified as law in the 1950s after a long and violent colonial history in the country. It culminated with the leadership of the National Party, which granted rights on the basis of skin color. Apartheid was, above all, an economic tool whereby the black and mixed-race populations (the former much more severely than the latter) were subordinated for white industry and wealth creation. Former President Mbeki uses a metaphor that I find quite illustrative: as a consequence of the above economic practices, the country has many small islands of vast wealth amidst a sea of staggering poverty.

The idea of ‘separate development’ was fundamental to Apartheid, especially after the international community started to condemn its practices and withdraw investment capital. So, the black population was given—or forcibly removed to—homelands or Bantustans where they could supposedly be semi-autonomous, but instead became a massive migratory labor reserve for white industry. In the process, almost 90% of the population was confined to roughly 13% of the (worst) land. Ultimately, this created an unhealthy, poverty-stricken black population. While political Apartheid fell in 1993 thanks to the dedication and courage of those in the liberation movement, the economic structures that propelled it remain entrenched, and the majority of South Africans are poorer today in relative terms than they were under Apartheid.

There is, of course, much more to the story—the Apartheid government was as nefarious as they come, modeling itself after Nazi Germany and freely condoning violent oppression. Through a process of racial ranking, ethnic tensions were created that are still rife today. The process of spatializing the country cannot be missed; the trip from the airport into downtown takes one through the Cape Flats, where millions of people live in what one might generously call shacks, but are really ramshackle structures composed of whatever refuse one can find. These people daily commute into Cape Town to work as domestic workers in some of the world’s most lavish homes or in the service industry—if they are lucky, because the unemployment rate in South Africa hovers around 40%.

There’s no getting around the fact that the picture is a grim one for the vast majority—and getting worse in many senses, but as I’ve said before, there are many examples of everyday courage, grace, and alternative visioning of South Africa’s future. The Community Health Media Trust is one such organization, so I’ll detail next time what I’m learning about new possibilities for living positively with HIV in this country.

My best,
T

Monday, October 26, 2009

The World Cup, etc.


I feel really settled now in Cape Town, in my neighborhood of Observatory, at UCT, and in my new house. You’ll see a picture of my little bungalow's patio in this posting. Additionally, a photo of UCT is included as is a playfully irreverent photo of the local ‘Trump Towers’—don’t alert The Donald, lest a lawsuit descend on the kind people of Observatory. I keep meeting new people—students at UCT, my housemates’ friends and colleagues, and the leagues of people in the Khan’s globe-spanning social circle.

I had the pleasure of acting as bartender Friday for Felicity’s birthday parties. Yes, parties plural. I worked doggedly all afternoon to keep cocktails in the hands of 25 ladies who attended party #1. This was no easy task given the insatiable thirst of these girls, including my favorite—Elizabeth—an 83 year-old woman who rejected my first whiskey on the rocks because it was of an inadequate quality and age. She then rejected #2 because it did not include enough whiskey. In the evening we held another party for 20 open to all; I took the backseat because the cooking was handled by others and we only drank wine and champagne (mercifully).

Saturday I went to another family’s twin daughters’ twenty-fifth birthday party in Greene Point, the trendy neighborhood in Cape Town that is being sharply manicured (read: cleared of all locals) for the upcoming World Cup. The gathering was fun and then I was taken on a mini tour of the neighborhood, which is very upscale for Cape Town. I have fine tastes, but even I cannot justify the purchase of a sterling silver melon baller.

The country is abuzz over the coming World Cup. There are ten stadiums being constructed or renovated in preparation for the big event in July (that state dollars are being dedicated to these stadiums amidst diffuse, abject poverty in the country is a matter of contentious debate). The bottom line is that everyone wants a piece of the perceived goldmine in the form of the infusion of international capital; the taxi drivers are, for instance, threatening to strike lest they receive a favorable contract from the city. I am thrilled to be leaving long before the chaos commences.

Should any of you be interested in picking up one of the year’s best new works of fiction, I am just finishing The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. It represents my favorite type of fiction: funny, tragic, informative, evocative, and historically rich. Check it out if you’re looking for solid entertainment and a little more knowledge about your world.

I’m finding that blogging is a bit of a challenge and my general status as chronically creatively stunted is manifest here—if there’s anything you’d like to hear about, please let me know.


Stay well,
Todd

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

New digs, South African time, & sorting it all out

As I sit here poolside in the sunshine typing this blog posting, I question the wisdom moving anywhere else, let alone into a small house with roommates...but alas I need to be a big boy and take care of myself. Through a contact at UCT, I connected with a woman leasing a room in her home; the house is located in my target neighborhood of Observatory, a youthful, artsy, lively community just outside the city center. Emma is a South African who works in the human rights NGO sector. Also in the house are her finance, an aspiring Nigerian novelist named Kolade, and a Dutch student earning a master’s degree in the Department of African Studies at UCT. Perks of the house include a) a security system with armed response, b) an outdoor shower, c) a great patio, and d) Kolade is supposed to be an excellent cook. Incidentally, the only other students I’ve met at UCT thus far also happen to know and love my new housemates, so I’m feeling good about that endorsement.

The Khans, as usual, treated me in princely fashion over the weekend. We went to two shows, the first being a dance/music/drama number called Partly God at the Artscape theater downtown. Saturday night we saw what I believe to be the Willie Nelson of South Africa, Jeremy Taylor. He is an enormously talented musician and storyteller. I felt a bit badly about taking even one seat in the theater because clearly this guy is a top act known universally to South Africans. I enjoyed myself immensely nonetheless... But Sunday was the real treat. If only I had pictures! I went to a church braii (barbeque) with the Khans on Sunday afternoon. Food was to commence immediately after the service, which let out at 10:30 am. We ate at 4:00. I had forgotten how casual the commitment is to time, schedules, etc. in South Africa until yesterday. The company and socializing was the priority and I had a wonderful time, but having skipped breakfast for what I presumed would be lunch, I had a voracious appetite when the food was finally served. Won’t make that mistake again. Incidentally, these people throw my kind of party. For roughly 40 people, there were four cases of wine, a case of whiskey, and a case of rum. They brought a refrigerator, multiple barbeques, real serving dishes and flatware, a children’s swimming pool for ice, etc. In addition, there was food for hundreds (when it was finally served!).

As for South Africa itself, it’s my friend and enemy. One is constantly reminded to never get too comfortable here. What I observe more than anything this time around are the class tensions in South Africa. Perhaps it is because I am currently staying in an affluent place, but people across different socioeconomic backgrounds (a gradient that is sharply raced) see and understand South African in such different ways that I wonder how these different life worlds will ever be reconciled. I guess because I travel easily between circles, I get this fuller perspective, but people don’t do much talking here because they are so deeply suspect of one-another. And my academic knowledge tells me that the gap between rich and poor is only widening. So, there’s a small nugget of my developing understanding of the place.

Cheers, and thanks to all of you who have been writing! Apologies for the lack of photos in this post--I forgot my camera cord, but will post some photos next time.

T

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

My new routine

I know many of you are waiting for me to offer some sort of pithy description of Cape Town or South Africa, but I feel a little disingenuous doing that just yet, though I am forming some thoughts as I go. A neighbor named Adela gave me a lift from the University back to the house today, and her summary was the best I've heard thus far: "South Africa has the best of the best and the worst of the worst." It is intensely beautiful with some of the kindest, most affable, and generous people I've ever met, but the history of apartheid has left it deeply fractured and with an uncertain future. That's the best I can offer right now. In the meantime, I thought I might tell you about my daily activities and routine so you can have a sense of my life world here in Cape Town (and so I can share a couple photographs).

I will be dividing my time between the University of Cape Town (UCT) libraries and the Community Health Media Trust (CHMT). At the former, I use media resources and policy documents to understand the evolving discourse surrounding HIV/AIDS in the country. Many of you know that South Africa's former president, Thabo Mbeki, is a notorious 'AIDS dissident', denying the link between HIV and AIDS, challenging the efficacy of antiretroviral therapy, and advocating for seemingly bizarre alternative treatments like dry cleaning solvents or beet root. His persistent denial of therapy to the country's nine million people with HIV has now been overcome thanks to the work of civil society organizations and health advocacy groups--the process of which I research through media and policy documents at UCT.



I also wrap my head around the work of these organizations through an internship with and research at CHMT, a Cape Town-based national organization focusing on the dissemination of scientific, non-biased information to people living with AIDS. CHMT staff members do this through many mediums and means: television, print media, health clinic outreach, radio, etc. I am assisting with some writing tasks; in return they are granting me access to their staff. I also have the rare opportunity to visit the community health centers with their outreach liaisons. I have not done the visits yet, but am very much looking forward to the opportunity. The pictures embedded in this posting are of their offices in Muizenberg, a suburb of Cape Town; the second is of the view from the office (dangerously, this office is located just opposite the beach--you know where I'll be after work!).

I hope this helps to better explain my research and fill you in on my daily routine. I'm still sorting out my permanent living arrangement, but must admit that I'm in no hurry to leave the wonderful digs I have at the moment--I could not ask for better hosts than the Khans. I'll make the move in the next week or so, however.

I hope each of you is well.

Cheers,
Todd