Wednesday, December 23, 2009

The Death of a Dubious Figure

Sorry folks, no photos with this one...I'll summarize the rest of my holiday vacation in the next few days and provide lots of photos there.

There was a significant death in South Africa this past week: the former Minister of Health, Manto Tshabala-Msimang died of liver failure. To say that she was a controversial character is an understatement. That’s like stating the obvious fact that George Bush was a controversial president. Tshabala-Msimang and former President Mbeki are the architects behind the delay in AIDS treatment for millions of South Africans. She never, ever would have assented to the provision of therapy if she had not been publicly flogged to such a degree that she relented and consorted with Mbeki to provide a sort of anemic therapy regime. The public response to her death has been anything but mournful. Rather, people feel that a bit of karmic intentionality may have been at work. She was on her second liver already, in line for a third when she died, and gained heaps of unwanted attention when she was exposed as demanding alcohol while still in the hospital after her first transplant.

Tshabala-Msimang was frequently referred to as Dr. Beetroot because she suggested that people take beetroot as an alternative to biomedical treatments for AIDS. The extent to which she believed the information she disseminated versus simply towing the line for Thabo Mbeki will likely forever remain a mystery. But what is clear is that she leaves a legacy of hugely negative proportions. At her funeral this week, President Zuma claimed she was an unsung hero of the anti-Apartheid struggle, which she may indeed be true, but her legacy will not surround such accomplishments.

Perhaps unfortunately, her work as a freedom fighter in exile has been obscured by the policies for which she advocated for eight years as Minister of Health in South Africa. She spoke fluent Russian, having received her medical training in Russia (which is an interesting story in itself: Russia trained legions of South Africans under the Communist regime as a sort of alliance amongst nations persecuted by the West (black and colored South Africa being perceived as persecuted by the West under the Apartheid system)). Her history with the ANC and the fight for liberation and democracy was a respectable one, but over the course of the last eight years she was demonized and vilified in the public eye. While I am loathe to celebrate the suffering or passing of human beings, and as someone earning an intellectual degree I feel I should not weigh in emotionally on this cause, I think there is just cause on both sides or the reactionary divide.

She was vilified, perhaps unfairly, for her role in delaying treatment for millions of South Africans living with HIV. She may have supported these policies or she may simply have supported the President and liked having a job. The Lancet, a British medical journal, recently incisively argued that this delay cost the lives of 330,000 South Africans. So you be the judge on that one. Alternatively, there are a lot of reasons to represent the perspective she did, namely that Western biomedicine is a WESTERN phenomenon, and black South Africans know to be deeply distrustful of anything Western, for it was the Western world, after all, that allowed the perpetuation of the Apartheid system for decades. And the introduction of Western biomedicine in South Africa to black South Africans was modeled along the lines of Nazi Germany, where the real goal was an extermination campaign, complete with horrific human experiments of sickening design.

At the end of the day I’m just very curious. Why did she really say what she did and enact such policies? Did she really believe that eating garlic and lemon could cure HIV? Did she really believe that the treatment so pervasive in the rest of the world was unsuited for her people? How could she witness mass death with such ambivalence? Or did she just want to make policies without white Westerners interfering with her work? I had hoped I or someone else might someday find the answers to these questions, through her own words, but her passing means that opportunity is now lost.

At the end of the day, I’m not a fan—far from it. She should have known better and she let allegiance to a party and a President cloud her judgment. But I DO reserve most of my judgment because I can’t creep around in the recesses of her brain, nor can I understand how Apartheid impacted her psyche. That’s my take, which is considerably less partial than the discourses circulating in South African currently.

Stay well,
Todd

1 comment:

  1. WOW! This is so interesting. Makes me think about how complex the AIDS movement in SA is and how in some ways it is simultaneously reinforcing another system of apartheid by denying rights to marginalized communities as well as deeply engrained in the anti-apartheid movement-i.e. resisting western influences. I can see that you have gained such a deep and complex understanding of SA particularly in politics. Thanks Diddy, Once again!!!!

    ReplyDelete