Some of you may have heard lately about the controversy surrounding South African President Jacob Zuma. Zuma is fast-becoming one of the best known polygamists in the world. He recently took his fifth wife and is in negotiations for wife number six. He is divorced from one wife and another committed suicide several years ago. He has fathered at least twenty children over the course of fifty years. Polygamy is really not the issue of contention in South Africa because this is a common and accepted practice, but his extra-marital affairs and what they represent are the subject of much criticism and debate.
In 2006 Zuma was tried on rape charges after he had sex with a young HIV-positive Treatment Action Campaign activist without using a condom. The trial was an epic spectacle, but he was ultimately exonerated. During this trial Zuma stated that showering after having sex with an HIV+ person will eliminate the risk of contracting HIV, a statement for which he will forever be (rightly) ridiculed. Regardless of the definition of rape and how one interprets the idea of forced submission, there is a general consensus that Zuma abused his power with this young woman who saw him as a leader, an elder to be respected, and someone to whom she owed total allegiance; she was not in a position to refuse his advances. She may not have been physically fighting him off, but this does not mean she was not forced against her will.
Then last week it was revealed that he is the father of a newborn extramarital child, the mother of whom is the daughter of one of his colleagues. And the revelations keep coming. So, obviously, there are many issues for discussion!
Respecting the fact that I am not a South African, nor a Zulu, I start from the position that there is nothing inherently morally wrong with polygamy, and subsequently wish to withhold moral judgment. Capital punishment is still legal in the United States, and I find this a significantly more immoral practice than polygamy, for instance. Polygamy is practiced all over the world and is at the end of the day just another family model, one that has functioned for time eternal. Where I feel I can extend judgment is in the fact that these unions tend to happen in places where women are oppressed and gender inequality is extreme. So, the extent to which women wish to engage in these unions is constrained by social context and the idea of choice must be critically understood. I venture that women tolerate this situations in part because there is no other model open to them.
My gravest concern lies around my area of research: HIV/AIDS. Zuma is a bad leader in this respect because he preaches one set of behaviors (condom use, faithfulness, abstinence) but then engages in others—a pregnancy outside wedlock is a) obviously a case of unprotected sex and b) an act of infidelity. In a country where young people are taught to emulate their elected leaders, it is dangerously irresponsible for Zuma to engage in such risky practices. He undermines his own credibility in acting this way. I heard a sound bite of Zuma speaking in Davos at the World Economic Forum last week, saying that polygamy is congruent with respecting women’s rights, a point on which I agree in principle I suppose (but life is often too messy for black-and-white principles!), but I do not necessarily think Zuma respects women’s rights…
I agree with most South African officials who have decided to drop the focus on single partnerships because this simply isn’t practical in South Africa or elsewhere. Instead they elect to focus on condom use. This is the best approach, in my opinion, until structural conditions change such that people value their own lives and have a less bleak future to look forward to. However, we can still judge Zuma on at least two fronts: 1) breaking his own marital bonds, sworn in marriage ceremonies, and 2) engaging in practices that literally risk lives. The third big one is, of course, the extent to which he claims his culture’s tolerance of polygamy is a disguise for oppressing women. I don’t feel comfortable touching the last topic because I don’t know how to do so without being a cultural imperialist or without at least engaging in a deep dialogue with a Zulu. So I’ll leave that to the Zulus to sort out.
I hope this posting sounds balanced and fair and that I’ve provided some background on this contentious topic. I understand from my parents that Zuma has got some international press lately, so I hope this posting is timely as well.
Incidentally, I actually SAW Zuma yesterday afternoon when he drove past Declan and I on the way to make his state of the nation address at the opening of parliament. He did look stressed!
Cheers,
Todd
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment