The above phrase is one I never ever use because it presumes that race and ethnicity are some sort of chip in a high stakes card game, rather than very real (though anthropogenic) forces that forcefully shape human beings’ lives and experiences. Yet I hear the phrase tossed about all the time here in South Africa; whenever a problematic social issue is brought to the fore, people of all stripes will jump to an explanation of racism when responding to their detractors. Beyond the fact that racism is entrenched and pervasive, I think this impulse reflects many other things, including attempts to obscure the real issue under scrutiny. Social issues in South Africa are of such a staggering magnitude that no one seems able offer a tenable (palatable to those in power?) solution; tossing a claim of racism back into your opponents face when threatened is an quick way to wiggle out of the controversy. For instance, recently we had a problem at our house whereby some neighbors were making excessive noise in the street in the early morning hours. Emma, who is white, asked them, who are black, to stop the racket or at least tone it down. They immediately and unequivocally accused her of being racist. Save the fact that she could drag her black fiancĂ© out of the house to offer evidence to the contrary, in the moment she was at a total loss. The issue was a compelling one for me because it mirrored the same discourse I have been observing in the political arena. When we discussed it later having had time to reflect on the situation, Emma said she felt their response meant, “Don’t think you can tell me what to do, white woman.”
Similarly, a vicious fight is currently occurring between the African National Congress (ANC) and the South African Communist Party (SACP), the latter composed of many white and colored people unlike the ANC. When a person’s leadership is criticized on either side, racism is blamed versus examining the veracity of the claim. Meanwhile, the topics of redistribution and progress get sidelined. The same situation occurred when President Mbeki was criticized for his stance on AIDS; he flatly stated that his detractors were imperial Western racists, a claim that left his opposition in a very precarious position because the last thing they wanted was to be perceived as racist. Like anything, I seek to dig below the surface to explore the ‘real’ issue. And, to be clear, I know that racism exists and has power beyond my capacity to comprehend. I just think that in this context it is a purveyor of other unstated social issues simmering just below the surface.
The challenge with blame casting like this quick reliance on racism as a motivator is that it obscures the actual issue of inquiry. Here is what I feel that I know for sure: The way that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the body created to address the violence and injustice of Apartheid, operated left much to be desired. It was non-punitive, meaning people could confess their criminal acts without consequence. And it was voluntary so very few people ever got involved. This meant two key things: 1) those culpable for Apartheid’s grievous injustices were never punished, and 2) white people, particularly Afrikaners, were never forced to explicitly state that Apartheid was morally wrong. Add to this that white South Africans also managed to maintain ownership of industry and capital in South Africa such that their position within the country has only been enhanced (at the fall of Apartheid, the average white family was four times richer than the average black family; now that number is a factor of seven). So racial lines of difference matter very much but they must be framed appropriately as a consequence of economic choices and social restructuring post-Apartheid, particularly the choice to measure all social progress via market mechanisms.
In the meantime, the vision of progress in South Africa has become a strictly material one—each person out for themselves to make a buck and acquire possessions. The individual is the unit to be promoted and family structures have virtually vanished as people are continually fleeced of the means of survival. This is a consequence, I believe, of the influence of Western policies and the World Bank’s growth strategies for the country. The black population has taken on this agenda uncritically, which then infuriates the white population, both on principle and because there is the entrenched desire to not see black people well off. There is also a small but growing black bourgeoisie that is very visible, which represents a real challenge for the white population.
Ultimately, what I am saying is that the issue of race was never actually meaningfully addressed, particularly how race is a purveyor for all sorts of other social maladies like economic injustice, political disenfranchisement, etc. Because of this there is still no recognition of the fact that black people are poor due to structural conditions, not because of some sort of endemic inferiority. Now important matters of race have just become an easy fallback counter-claim in a country where there are no easy solutions. The choice to always invoke racism channels the fact that the race issue has never effectively been addressed and there has been very little healing post-Apartheid. In some senses, I believe that the gulfs dividing people are wider today than ever before. Racial disparities and attendant structural violence need to be addressed but to do so requires changing the system in a fundamental way, which those in power (black, white, colored, Indian, whomever) are strikingly unwilling, or feel paralyzed, to pursue. Until race is seen in it’s totality as a contextual social factor, I think its current use only serves to eclipse real issues at hand.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment