While I am flattered that people think I have the capacity to address such a massive problem with my tiny little brain, this is not a challenge I identified at the start of this endeavor. You see, I have a diagnostic problem. Conceptually, I want to connect the face of HIV/AIDS to everything from the arrival of the Dutch 400 years ago to contemporary economic policies favoring growth above any sort of human betterment to my realization that HIV/AIDS will never be addressed without comprehensive sex education in public schools. I promise that this isn’t a cop-out on my part; rather, I do not, under any circumstances, want to become one of those international global health bureaucrats whose work I so trenchantly critique.
My frustration with the cadres of global health practitioners is twofold: first, they focus almost exclusively on technical solutions for what a fundamentally social problems (e.g. focusing on circumcising all men versus remediating gender-based violence). This then limits the types of questions they ask and the interventions they advocate to something that can be prescribed (medicines, condoms, improved supply lines, etc.).
I have a good example with which to elucidate my claims/concerns. I have always thought that HIV/AIDS is a top concern of all South Africans because of the scope of its scourge and the way it is insidiously undermining the country (remember, 40% of women attending antenatal clinics are HIV+). I arrived operating under this assumption without asking the question first. It was only in the course of my first several interviews that I realized how low a priority HIV/AIDS really is on most poor people’s agenda. In front of HIV/AIDS they would put a) poverty, b) (un)employment, c) living conditions, d) their children’s education and potential, e) putting food on the table, and the list goes on. The consequences of HIV/AIDS seem fairly remote for people whose homes flood each time it rains or who rotate sexual partners for compensation to feed the kids.
Yet somehow HIV/AIDS is the sexy global health topic du jour, receiving seemingly unlimited amounts of money. I would argue that this is because we think there are all sorts of technical fixes for it, but also because it’s something we think we’ve figured out in the West and can easily export our knowledge across the globe. Not so I’m afraid. Somehow the picture just gets worse the more we try to intervene, yet where local people are empowered to develop solutions to the problems they identify, the outcomes are remarkable. This is why I love CHMT so much; a group of South Africans cognizant of local social realities devises their interventions and achieve laudable results.
I hope this post is informative and makes the case for thinking carefully about what we all know and don’t know such that we act humbly when called to prescribe from afar.
Cheers,
T
Thanks Todd!!! I totally agree with you. Also I think the west's focus on HIV/AIDS is very tangible adn covers up many of the structural inequalities that exist in global south that we in the west are perpetuating. This is so important to realize...thank you for writing about it!
ReplyDelete