Thursday, January 28, 2010

Why Can't South Africa 'Develop'?

The leaders of South Africa would have us believe that it is the rising sun of the African continent, the phoenix emerging from the ashes of a decayed continent. I do not share this sentiment, though I do think there are millions of everyday miracles, successes, and acts of heroism in South Africa. And I think South Africans know the way; they just need to be enabled to define their own course. It’s a bit of a ‘two steps forward, one step back’ situation at the current moment. Here’s my take on why:

First, Colonialism and the history of Apartheid left the country gutted of it’s natural resources and left the overwhelming majority of the population in a state of grinding poverty. The Apartheid economy was possible and so successful because it was built on the backs of some of the poorest people in the world’s labor. Now the task is for the democratic government to care for all of these people with the same resources that previously cared for less than fifteen percent of the population. These people are difficult to integrate into a developmental agenda because they lack skills, knowledge, and education; the knock-on effect is that even where a progressive agenda exists, there aren’t human resources to fill the void.

Second, debt. Apartheid was very expensive, especially in its waning years. As the years went on and the international community began to isolate South Africa, the situation became increasingly untenable. Maintenance of the Apartheid state was so costly because so many resources had to be used to suppress popular uprisings and keep 30 million people in a state of perpetual imprisonment. To fund this social experiment, the government eventually resorted to that age-old source of blood money, the World Bank. By the time Apartheid finally fell in 1994, the government had an international debt of 25 billion American dollars. The Bank has refused to forgive this debt post-Apartheid even when confronted with the way the money had been used and abused, so to this day South Africans are servicing the debt on the money used to violently oppress them. The country has not even started to pay down the principle and the new social programs have required a quick infusion of cash, meaning more loans. And the cycle continues...

Third, economic restructuring. In essence, the South African government promotes growth above all other benchmarks. So long as the macroeconomic situation looks good, leaders and international lenders are happy. The problem is that the fruits of this growth—which is real and there is more money circulating—is held by a very, very small group of people. To achieve this growth, taxes were cut, the currency devalued, environmental standards relaxed, labor power suppressed, etc., meaning the protections for the very poorest have been eliminated while wealth creation continues at a steady clip. Hence the widening of inequality and the deepening of poverty.

This last point is important. As I have alluded to before, progress has a strictly economic tone, so other measures of progress—like education attainment, gender equity, (un)employment statistics, etc. are backgrounded in favor of strict monetary growth. South Africa is a brilliant cautionary tale that elucidates the disconnects between the promises and reality of a trickle-down theory. The theory has failed catastrophically in South Africa over the past fifteen years and the country has followed the international financial institutions’ instructions with great precision.

I share the above information because people often ask me, “What’s the problem? Why can’t the place develop?” First, we must ask how we measure ‘development’ and then look at the big picture. I am always torn between thinking the situation is quite complex and the sense that really the problem is quite simple, with the latter usually dominating my thinking. There is a way out of this but it requires a paradigm shift the likes of which are not likely to occur anytime soon.

A fun blog posting next time, I promise.

My best,
T

Friday, January 22, 2010

The race card

The above phrase is one I never ever use because it presumes that race and ethnicity are some sort of chip in a high stakes card game, rather than very real (though anthropogenic) forces that forcefully shape human beings’ lives and experiences. Yet I hear the phrase tossed about all the time here in South Africa; whenever a problematic social issue is brought to the fore, people of all stripes will jump to an explanation of racism when responding to their detractors. Beyond the fact that racism is entrenched and pervasive, I think this impulse reflects many other things, including attempts to obscure the real issue under scrutiny. Social issues in South Africa are of such a staggering magnitude that no one seems able offer a tenable (palatable to those in power?) solution; tossing a claim of racism back into your opponents face when threatened is an quick way to wiggle out of the controversy. For instance, recently we had a problem at our house whereby some neighbors were making excessive noise in the street in the early morning hours. Emma, who is white, asked them, who are black, to stop the racket or at least tone it down. They immediately and unequivocally accused her of being racist. Save the fact that she could drag her black fiancĂ© out of the house to offer evidence to the contrary, in the moment she was at a total loss. The issue was a compelling one for me because it mirrored the same discourse I have been observing in the political arena. When we discussed it later having had time to reflect on the situation, Emma said she felt their response meant, “Don’t think you can tell me what to do, white woman.”

Similarly, a vicious fight is currently occurring between the African National Congress (ANC) and the South African Communist Party (SACP), the latter composed of many white and colored people unlike the ANC. When a person’s leadership is criticized on either side, racism is blamed versus examining the veracity of the claim. Meanwhile, the topics of redistribution and progress get sidelined. The same situation occurred when President Mbeki was criticized for his stance on AIDS; he flatly stated that his detractors were imperial Western racists, a claim that left his opposition in a very precarious position because the last thing they wanted was to be perceived as racist. Like anything, I seek to dig below the surface to explore the ‘real’ issue. And, to be clear, I know that racism exists and has power beyond my capacity to comprehend. I just think that in this context it is a purveyor of other unstated social issues simmering just below the surface.

The challenge with blame casting like this quick reliance on racism as a motivator is that it obscures the actual issue of inquiry. Here is what I feel that I know for sure: The way that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the body created to address the violence and injustice of Apartheid, operated left much to be desired. It was non-punitive, meaning people could confess their criminal acts without consequence. And it was voluntary so very few people ever got involved. This meant two key things: 1) those culpable for Apartheid’s grievous injustices were never punished, and 2) white people, particularly Afrikaners, were never forced to explicitly state that Apartheid was morally wrong. Add to this that white South Africans also managed to maintain ownership of industry and capital in South Africa such that their position within the country has only been enhanced (at the fall of Apartheid, the average white family was four times richer than the average black family; now that number is a factor of seven). So racial lines of difference matter very much but they must be framed appropriately as a consequence of economic choices and social restructuring post-Apartheid, particularly the choice to measure all social progress via market mechanisms.

In the meantime, the vision of progress in South Africa has become a strictly material one—each person out for themselves to make a buck and acquire possessions. The individual is the unit to be promoted and family structures have virtually vanished as people are continually fleeced of the means of survival. This is a consequence, I believe, of the influence of Western policies and the World Bank’s growth strategies for the country. The black population has taken on this agenda uncritically, which then infuriates the white population, both on principle and because there is the entrenched desire to not see black people well off. There is also a small but growing black bourgeoisie that is very visible, which represents a real challenge for the white population.

Ultimately, what I am saying is that the issue of race was never actually meaningfully addressed, particularly how race is a purveyor for all sorts of other social maladies like economic injustice, political disenfranchisement, etc. Because of this there is still no recognition of the fact that black people are poor due to structural conditions, not because of some sort of endemic inferiority. Now important matters of race have just become an easy fallback counter-claim in a country where there are no easy solutions. The choice to always invoke racism channels the fact that the race issue has never effectively been addressed and there has been very little healing post-Apartheid. In some senses, I believe that the gulfs dividing people are wider today than ever before. Racial disparities and attendant structural violence need to be addressed but to do so requires changing the system in a fundamental way, which those in power (black, white, colored, Indian, whomever) are strikingly unwilling, or feel paralyzed, to pursue. Until race is seen in it’s totality as a contextual social factor, I think its current use only serves to eclipse real issues at hand.

Monday, January 18, 2010

The South African Countryside

I am a city boy. This should be no surprise to anyone who has ever met me. I find the country and nature pleasant to look at and explore, especially if a picnic is involved, but I have also never really felt embraced by country folk, for whatever reason. And I don’t take offense at this; I am not looking to relocate to a rural setting. The South African countryside has both confirmed and complicated my country discomfort, depending on the places and people I have visited. The one constant here is that the inland countryside is bloody hot and dusty. I love the heat, but not this kind of heat (at not least without a nearby pool and cocktail) and dust has never particularly suited my sensibilities. Oh, and the bugs! These bugs could eat an infant with a single bite.

Yesterday for the second time I went with the Khans to the hamlet of Suurbraak, a picturesque and sleepy little town about two and a half hours west of Cape Town. The Khans are sponsoring a village improvement project whereby they provide funds and expertise to a town council seeking to develop certain facilities and capacities in the village. One thing I really appreciate about the Khans’ approach is that they ask the residents of Suurbraak what they want rather than identifying places for improvement as outsiders. When they first approached the village, the people requested a fence around the nursery school, which everyone thought was a fine idea, presuming that the townspeople did not want the children to wander away. But the reason for this request is the interesting part: local deer were wandering onto the grounds to munch on the foliage, dropping deer ticks in the process, which carry diseases that are then transferred to the kids and staff of the school. I thought this was an excellent cautionary tale in asking what locals want because I can assure you that no development ‘expert’ would ever think of this problem.

Alternatively, I find the Afrikaaner population, the white Dutch-descendant population dispersed throughout South Africa, to be quite an unpleasant crowd—they are fiercely insular and almost uniformly opposed to democratic progress and social change in the country. This is painting with a broad brush because I have met people who sharply counter this trend, but nonetheless Afrikaaners have a way of life that is difficult to penetrate on any level. And I think these people would tell you that they like it this way, so I’m not offering any sort of unwarranted critique here.

The topography of the country varies dramatically from desert to craggy peaks to rolling agricultural hills and so on. Covering the whole tip of the southern African continent, South Africa also has exquisite beaches at every turn. To be honest, I have actually seen very, very little of the country myself, having never even travelled outside the Western Cape province. I am going with my housemate Emma to a place called Nature’s Valley in a couple weeks; this place is in the Eastern Cape and will provide a lot more exposure as it is eight hours away from Cape Town.

Like Cape Town, there are great extremes in socioeconomic status and well-being across the inland, though I think the disparities are less extreme than those found in Cape Town; without the comparison that is so easy in big cities, I think people are either more content to do with less or don’t know any different. Suurbraak has a population of very poor people (who make well under $100 per month) but they’re also some of the kindest, gentlest people I’ve met (it is a coloured, or mixed race, town)—which is a stark contrast to their comparatively much better off Afrikaner neighbors. I’m not one to romanticize poverty, but I do think it inspires a sort of collectivity and community unseen in other, particularly urban, environments.

Perhaps yesterday’s best find was this huge country store where they sell everything, including antiques. The Khans bought a bunch of stuff, including an antique European chest for less than $200! I bought cheese. Check it out.

Back to serious topics next time (not that rural poverty isn’t serious!), but enjoy these fun pictures in the meantime.

I hope that each of you is well.

Cheers,
Todd

Monday, January 11, 2010

Solutions to HIV/AIDS in South Africa?

Whenever I meet someone new in South Africa, they naturally probe me about the nature of my dissertation research, the content of which I am always a bit sheepish about sharing. There are a number of reasons for this: 1) I am very, perhaps overly, committed to this project and the people with whom I work, and want to protect the sanctity of what we’re producing together, 2) they often immediately offer their own perspective on the matter, which sometimes sharply contrasts with my own understanding, leaving us at a bit of an awkward standstill, but the biggest problem is 3) they often want to know what I am going to do with this knowledge or, more specifically, what policies should be implemented to improve HIV/AIDS care.

While I am flattered that people think I have the capacity to address such a massive problem with my tiny little brain, this is not a challenge I identified at the start of this endeavor. You see, I have a diagnostic problem. Conceptually, I want to connect the face of HIV/AIDS to everything from the arrival of the Dutch 400 years ago to contemporary economic policies favoring growth above any sort of human betterment to my realization that HIV/AIDS will never be addressed without comprehensive sex education in public schools. I promise that this isn’t a cop-out on my part; rather, I do not, under any circumstances, want to become one of those international global health bureaucrats whose work I so trenchantly critique.

My frustration with the cadres of global health practitioners is twofold: first, they focus almost exclusively on technical solutions for what a fundamentally social problems (e.g. focusing on circumcising all men versus remediating gender-based violence). This then limits the types of questions they ask and the interventions they advocate to something that can be prescribed (medicines, condoms, improved supply lines, etc.). Second, they seem way more comfortable than I am in telling other people how best to live their lives. My problem with offering a prescription is that it presumes I know enough about this place and its attendant cultural milieu; this, I find, is really tantamount to saying that the way I live my life is superior and that I am equipped with the best tools to address their problems . This is ultimately one of the reasons I chose to pursue an intellectual degree—I get to explore these issues and weigh in only when I feel like I can conscionably do so.

I have a good example with which to elucidate my claims/concerns. I have always thought that HIV/AIDS is a top concern of all South Africans because of the scope of its scourge and the way it is insidiously undermining the country (remember, 40% of women attending antenatal clinics are HIV+). I arrived operating under this assumption without asking the question first. It was only in the course of my first several interviews that I realized how low a priority HIV/AIDS really is on most poor people’s agenda. In front of HIV/AIDS they would put a) poverty, b) (un)employment, c) living conditions, d) their children’s education and potential, e) putting food on the table, and the list goes on. The consequences of HIV/AIDS seem fairly remote for people whose homes flood each time it rains or who rotate sexual partners for compensation to feed the kids.

Yet somehow HIV/AIDS is the sexy global health topic du jour, receiving seemingly unlimited amounts of money. I would argue that this is because we think there are all sorts of technical fixes for it, but also because it’s something we think we’ve figured out in the West and can easily export our knowledge across the globe. Not so I’m afraid. Somehow the picture just gets worse the more we try to intervene, yet where local people are empowered to develop solutions to the problems they identify, the outcomes are remarkable. This is why I love CHMT so much; a group of South Africans cognizant of local social realities devises their interventions and achieve laudable results.

I hope this post is informative and makes the case for thinking carefully about what we all know and don’t know such that we act humbly when called to prescribe from afar.

Cheers,
T

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Happy New Year

Happy New Year Friends,

Though not the focus of this post, I have included some photos of my New Year’s celebration at the Khans’ house (because they’re fun photos and because this post is difficult to capture in photos). While flexibility is today’s theme, I want to start with a fun story that I can’t resist sharing.

The other day my housemate Rein and I went to the beach. We rented boogie boards and had a great time riding waves on the Indian Ocean side of the cape. After an hour or so of this, there is this sudden mass pandemonium: whistles blowing, sirens blaring, parents fetching their children from the water, etc. Rein and I watch in interest, only to see that everyone (everyone!) is staring at this certain (nearby) point in the water. I look over and--to my absolute horror--see this huge pack of very large sharks in the swimming area. It was a Jaws-like scene: big fins slicing through the water. I boogied on my boogie board directly out of the water! It was the coolest/scariest thing I’ve ever seen. Ever since little Jesse Arbogast’s Dad had to retrieve the poor kid’s arm from a shark’s jaws in Florida, I’ve been scared of sharks, and this experience taught me to be hyper-vigilant (and that the creatures are really, really big!).

Anyway, onto the point of this post: I have become a much more flexible person since arriving in South Africa. While I believe this is a character trait to cultivate, the process of getting to this point has involved all kinds of toil, and has at times been dramatic or maddening or both. For instance, today I stepped in a deep puddle of sewage wearing only flip-flops. I only realized later in the day how totally unphased I was by this revolting misfortune. I simply stepped out of the hole, found a water tap, washed my foot and sandal, and carried on with my day. While sloshing about in sewage is actually a rare occasion in sanitary Cape Town, other experiences in the city have taught me to just roll with life’s unfortunate developments.

As I’ve written about previously, public transport requires every last ounce of patience I have. A couple weeks ago I was on my way to the Khans' house, hoping to be there at a specified time. I have to take the train halfway and then a taxi for the second half of the journey. Upon arriving at the taxi rank, I discovered to my utmost dismay that the taxi drivers (only on my line) were on strike over a compensation issue with the taxi owners. What ensued was a veritable comedy of errors where I tried to end the strike, co-opt drivers from other routes, find alternate transportation, etc. all to no avail. Eventually a fight broke out between the owners and drivers, after which the frustrated passengers began hurling vegetables and other rotten refuse at the parties responsible for the strike. I was all too eager to join in the protest. I like to think of it as my first peasant uprising, though it was not at all successful. And, it’s important to note that, unlike most people, I was able to hitch a ride with a friend after the strike became interminable.

At the end of the day, however, not having my own car is really good for me. It forces me to be resourceful, walk frequently, and taking public transport is how I get a real pulse on the city.

Another excellent example: meeting at a pre-arranged time. I often arrange for appointments with folks in and around Cape Town. When I arrive, I am often met with, “You’re here NOW?” My response is generally to remind the person of the fact that we agreed on this meeting time. “You mean the taxis were on time?” they might ask or “Just give me an hour”. In these situations, I’ve learned that if I have to wait for an hour and a half, it’s no big deal. South Africans are very familiar with waiting around for an entire day for an appointment or struggling with public transport, thus making them tardy. People must be flexible here out of necessity (because so many factors are unpredictable on a daily basis) but also because life has a different pace where people don’t get worked up over lesser issues like a late arrival. Open Days with CHMT have been the best patience-building experience of my life; they’re a lot of fun but I spend hours in the hot, hot, hot sun waiting for the DJ, waiting for lunch, waiting for transport, or any other time-gobbling factors. It’s not because of some sort of incompetence but just because things work differently--so hopefully when you see me again you’ll observe much greater tolerance and patience.

But really I’ve learned to relax. I have had to retrain myself since being here to just chill and do nothing at times. And this is OK. I have made excellent progress on my project, and am way ahead of schedule, which sometimes leaves me with down time. Initially I tried to find ‘productive’ ways to fill spaces of time, but I’ve learned through observation that sitting around chatting with friends is an OK way to spend an entire Wednesday afternoon. The other day I was chuckling because at 3pm on a Tuesday all of my roommates and I were sound asleep, taking siestas that would seem like an illicit indulgence at home. This pace change has been good for me. I know this because I have slept like a baby through every night I’ve been here, never being stressed about other commitments or other not-so-acute concerns.

So, what I mean to say is, this is another way in which this experience and South Africa are good for me. This is a life pace that suits me (and allows a lot of time for reading and exercise); I’ll do my best to bring it home with me.

Wishing you all a wonderful 2010!

All the best,
Todd

Friday, December 25, 2009

A good thing comes to an end...

I had to say goodbye to my parents yesterday evening after a glorious two-week holiday. It was terrible to part ways, perhaps made more difficult because of the wonderful time we had together. I experienced South Africa in many new ways while they were here, some of which are shared below. Any of you reading this blog must consider vacationing in South Africa—it really is a world-class destination offering a diverse array of rich experiences. Even my notoriously difficult-to-please father called it his favorite ever vacation destination!

After our three days in the wine lands of Stellenbosch and Franschhoek—during which we ate and drank ourselves into a near coma—we made our way to the town of Rawsonville, ostensibly as our departure point for a daylong safari we had scheduled for the 21st of December. I am sometimes reminded of the fact that I am descended from a long line of peasants, and really am one myself, and my experience of Rawsonville affirmed this again given that it was my favorite part of the whole trip. The town is a very sleepy little place in the mountain foothills, and our guest house was situated in an agricultural valley. We stayed on a working wine farm once owned by the governor of the Western Cape province. The main home was a stunning Dutch Cape home built several hundred years ago and we stayed in an oh-so-charming converted staff cottage with a huge veranda overlooking the vineyards, mountains, and sunsets. This place put me into such a state of relaxation that I could hardly be bothered to eat meals (I was not, however, challenged in my wine consumption).

But this wasn’t even the best part of the place! A ten minute walk into the hills behind the house led to the most picturesque and Eden-like place I’ve ever been: a water fall cascading into a deep, clear, and warm rock pool. I spent every possible moment swimming in this slice of paradise, and when I wasn’t there I was thinking about being there.

As I said, our purpose for visiting Rawsonville was a safari at the Aquila Game Reserve. What a treat! We were met by a ranger with champagne in hand upon arrival, were treated to indulgent meals the whole day through, had champagne breaks DURING the safari, and swam in a stunning pool when finished. Oh, but we were there to see the animals… We saw elephants, rhinos, giraffes, lions, cheetahs, hippos, buffalo, zebras, springbok, and lions, among others. These creatures really are magnificent and the whole experience was one of those once-in-a-lifetime treats that I’ll treasure forever.

After Rawsonville and the safari, our final destination was a little village south of Cape Town called Simons Town. This place is known principally for the penguins that hang out at a little beach in the area called Boulders Beach. It is also the closest infrastructure to Cape Point, the point at the confluence of the Indian and Atlantic Oceans. While in Simons Town we chilled with the penguins, explored Cape Point and the Cape of Good Hope, ate lots of good food, and mostly relaxed as a family over the Christmas holiday. We had an amazing Cuban dinner for Christmas Eve and then celebrated the actual holiday at the Khans’ with some of their friends and family.

On the whole, I could not ask for a more successful trip. I am beat from all the travels and taking some time for recovery, but will be rested and able to apply fresh eyes and intellect to my project when I pick it up again early in the New Year.

I hope each of you has enjoyed the holiday season to this point and I wish you only the best in 2010.

Cheers,
Todd

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

The Death of a Dubious Figure

Sorry folks, no photos with this one...I'll summarize the rest of my holiday vacation in the next few days and provide lots of photos there.

There was a significant death in South Africa this past week: the former Minister of Health, Manto Tshabala-Msimang died of liver failure. To say that she was a controversial character is an understatement. That’s like stating the obvious fact that George Bush was a controversial president. Tshabala-Msimang and former President Mbeki are the architects behind the delay in AIDS treatment for millions of South Africans. She never, ever would have assented to the provision of therapy if she had not been publicly flogged to such a degree that she relented and consorted with Mbeki to provide a sort of anemic therapy regime. The public response to her death has been anything but mournful. Rather, people feel that a bit of karmic intentionality may have been at work. She was on her second liver already, in line for a third when she died, and gained heaps of unwanted attention when she was exposed as demanding alcohol while still in the hospital after her first transplant.

Tshabala-Msimang was frequently referred to as Dr. Beetroot because she suggested that people take beetroot as an alternative to biomedical treatments for AIDS. The extent to which she believed the information she disseminated versus simply towing the line for Thabo Mbeki will likely forever remain a mystery. But what is clear is that she leaves a legacy of hugely negative proportions. At her funeral this week, President Zuma claimed she was an unsung hero of the anti-Apartheid struggle, which she may indeed be true, but her legacy will not surround such accomplishments.

Perhaps unfortunately, her work as a freedom fighter in exile has been obscured by the policies for which she advocated for eight years as Minister of Health in South Africa. She spoke fluent Russian, having received her medical training in Russia (which is an interesting story in itself: Russia trained legions of South Africans under the Communist regime as a sort of alliance amongst nations persecuted by the West (black and colored South Africa being perceived as persecuted by the West under the Apartheid system)). Her history with the ANC and the fight for liberation and democracy was a respectable one, but over the course of the last eight years she was demonized and vilified in the public eye. While I am loathe to celebrate the suffering or passing of human beings, and as someone earning an intellectual degree I feel I should not weigh in emotionally on this cause, I think there is just cause on both sides or the reactionary divide.

She was vilified, perhaps unfairly, for her role in delaying treatment for millions of South Africans living with HIV. She may have supported these policies or she may simply have supported the President and liked having a job. The Lancet, a British medical journal, recently incisively argued that this delay cost the lives of 330,000 South Africans. So you be the judge on that one. Alternatively, there are a lot of reasons to represent the perspective she did, namely that Western biomedicine is a WESTERN phenomenon, and black South Africans know to be deeply distrustful of anything Western, for it was the Western world, after all, that allowed the perpetuation of the Apartheid system for decades. And the introduction of Western biomedicine in South Africa to black South Africans was modeled along the lines of Nazi Germany, where the real goal was an extermination campaign, complete with horrific human experiments of sickening design.

At the end of the day I’m just very curious. Why did she really say what she did and enact such policies? Did she really believe that eating garlic and lemon could cure HIV? Did she really believe that the treatment so pervasive in the rest of the world was unsuited for her people? How could she witness mass death with such ambivalence? Or did she just want to make policies without white Westerners interfering with her work? I had hoped I or someone else might someday find the answers to these questions, through her own words, but her passing means that opportunity is now lost.

At the end of the day, I’m not a fan—far from it. She should have known better and she let allegiance to a party and a President cloud her judgment. But I DO reserve most of my judgment because I can’t creep around in the recesses of her brain, nor can I understand how Apartheid impacted her psyche. That’s my take, which is considerably less partial than the discourses circulating in South African currently.

Stay well,
Todd