Monday, February 22, 2010

The Hotbox Wedding & the Mountain Climb

Greetings friends. Time for a fun blog post. I live with three people, two of whom were engaged until Saturday when they were formally married. Emma is South African and Kolade is Nigerian, so the ceremony was a hybrid of traditions, making for a fun and entertaining day. Their wonderful personalities plus the most amusing, dynamic, and engaging pastor I’ve ever met made for a really enjoyable ceremony. We ended by collectively singing a song called One More Step Along the World I Go, which has to be the best wedding song I’ve ever heard. If you’re getting married anytime soon, consider adding this one to your ceremony.

I was very excited for the big day until I saw the weather forecast for the day of the ceremony. Bloody hot would be an apt description. The moment I stepped outside Saturday morning, I regretted offering to do setup with my roommate Rein before the ceremony. Even at 10am when there were four of us in the reception hall it was blistering hot and I had a vigorous tropical sweat pouring down my body. By the time the 2pm ceremony rolled around, Cape Town was boiling at near 100 degrees Fahrenheit and the humidity was unbearable. Unfortunately, the ceremony was not held in one the Cape’s many old, cool stone churches, but rather in a building that was apparently designed to trap heat and prevent air flow. It was much like I imagine purgatory. The full mass lasted for an hour and a half and by the time it was over I was literally drenched in sweat, ready to curl up and die.

But that’s beside the point. The union of the bride and groom was the order of the day and it was a smashing success. A small miracle occurred the day before the wedding when the South African embassy finally granted Kolade’s family their visas for travel to Cape Town. So, they flew all night were literally collected at the airport and whisked off to the church in what was definitely a down-to-the-wire scheduling matter. And was I ever glad they were there. Talk about a punch of color! It was neat because mom, dad, brother, and sister were all dressed in clothes cut from the same stunning white embroidered cloth and then wrapped in an orange bolt of cloth at some place on their bodies.

It was also a fun experience for me because virtually everyone I know and care about in Cape Town was at the wedding (this one is of me with Theresa, my other Cape Town Mom), which was bittersweet because I know I’ll be leaving them all very soon. I would have liked to stay for the dancing and take more pictures, etc., but in case my earlier words did not adequately make it clear, it was too damn hot and humid to move, let alone participate in a wild party. I drove back with the Khans along the seashore in an attempt to cool down and then dipped into the pool as soon as I got home.

Some pictures are posted here; I apologize that they are not better, but I didn’t have the energy to use my camera. Most of these were taken by Declan.

Sunday’s weather was the exact inverse. I awoke to low clouds and cooler temperatures, which was great because I was scheduled to climb Table Mountain with some friends. To say I ‘climbed’ the mountain does not do the experience justice because I actually used all fours to gain several thousand feet in elevation through a scramble called Skeleton Gorge. About halfway up, we entered the cloud canopy, which moistened the rocks, giving them about as much grip as a buttered turkey. Eventually, the ‘path’ becomes so narrow and steep that there are only ladders or chains to climb, which is cool but intense. Anyway, it was an awesome trip, dampened only by the clouds and the lack of a view at the top. I was charged with bringing the champagne, which I duly did, and enjoyed very much. A photo of this is attached as well.

All love,
T

Thursday, February 18, 2010

On Suffering & Loss

One of the really tragic parts of my research is the near constant exposure to devastating stories. Actually, that statement applies to the whole of sub-Saharan Africa. But because my work involves HIV, a deadly virus, and working with poor people--those who are substantially more likely to experience untimely loss--I frequently hear tales of suffering and woe that shake me to the core. But it’s not just HIV that generates harrowing stories. A whole host of other factors generate tales of misery. Stories like this will challenge any belief in a benevolent power in the universe and force one to ponder deep philosophical questions.

I took a cab home from dinner the other night and the driver was a Rwandan refugee. As I always do, I got to amicably chatting with him, learning of his story and the odyssey that brought him to South Africa. He said he had to flee the country during the early 1990s civil war and came to South Africa via several other countries. The kicker came when I asked him if his family was in Cape Town. He very matter-of-factly responded that his wife and children had all been killed in the genocide and that he was the only surviving member of his family. I tend to not be at a loss in any conversational setting, but his admissions seemed to suck all the air out of the car at once, leaving me breathless and a little light-headed, both because it was such a startling revelation and because it spoke of a type of loss and suffering with which I have never been in such close contact.

I conduct a significant amount of work with nine Treatment Literacy Practitioners (TLPs), five of whom are HIV+. The other four have experiences with HIV that have driven them into the field. Lungi has lost a brother and a sister to HIV. Busi is HIV+ has lost an infant daughter. Nokuzola is also HIV+ has a son living with HIV. Zulkisa is single-handedly supporting two sisters who are living with HIV. The ways in which this disease has stricken communities cannot be captured in words, but suffice it to say that HIV leaves in its wake a sea of sadness. In fact, many people have told me that their friends and family are only jarred into caring about HIV when they lose a loved one to it.

There is a lovely restaurant in my neighborhood called A Touch of Madness; it is so nice, in fact, that I took my parents there for dinner when they were here. Just a couple weeks ago the staff at the restaurant experienced a terrible tragedy when one of the servers was stabbed to death in a senseless, random act of violence outside his township home; the perpetrators stole his mobile phone. He stepped outside to make a phone call and never returned, leaving a wife and three young children. Also of late, several students have been murdered nearby in robberies or simply random acts of violence.

Anyway, I am not attempting to regale leaders with horror stories, but rather to show how our world creates spaces of terrible suffering that we have a responsibility to chip away at as we are able. None of the phenomena are distinctly South African, but rather have a long history of which we are all a part. I think we in the West also have this perception that people who experience loss routinely are more easily able to process it, which may even be true on some level, but when these stories are relayed, they are indeed tales of anguish. I can see why people get so motivated when coming here and feel like they must do something to contribute, as I suppose I do too, but as I’ve detailed before, answering the how question is a much bigger challenge.

Generally, I see two sorts of responses to examples like those above, both problematic in my opinion. First, there are those who get hooked on this type of urban madness and stay tuned like they’re reading an addictive book. I learned quickly that reading the news each morning is a harrowing task in itself, and I quickly found myself becoming paranoid and obsessed, so I’ve elected to read the news less frequently. The alternative is those who just seal themselves off from the world, not wanting to hear about the extent of violence around them. While I understand the latter impulse because it is the only way to preserve one’s sanity, I think this also presumes that this type of violence is simply a given and that we can’t all contribute to a world without it.

It’s unfortunate to be surrounded by this type of tragedy so constantly, but I suppose it puts things like everyday inconveniences into perspective.

My housemates Emma and Kolade are getting married on Saturday, so my next post will be about the wedding, which I imagine will be--at the very least--a colorful affair. Then it's time for vacation with Amber Pearson, who arrives on Tuesday.

All the best to those in the Northern Hemisphere, where I hope the days are starting to feel longer.

Cheers,
Todd

Friday, February 12, 2010

Jacob Zuma

Some of you may have heard lately about the controversy surrounding South African President Jacob Zuma. Zuma is fast-becoming one of the best known polygamists in the world. He recently took his fifth wife and is in negotiations for wife number six. He is divorced from one wife and another committed suicide several years ago. He has fathered at least twenty children over the course of fifty years. Polygamy is really not the issue of contention in South Africa because this is a common and accepted practice, but his extra-marital affairs and what they represent are the subject of much criticism and debate.

In 2006 Zuma was tried on rape charges after he had sex with a young HIV-positive Treatment Action Campaign activist without using a condom. The trial was an epic spectacle, but he was ultimately exonerated. During this trial Zuma stated that showering after having sex with an HIV+ person will eliminate the risk of contracting HIV, a statement for which he will forever be (rightly) ridiculed. Regardless of the definition of rape and how one interprets the idea of forced submission, there is a general consensus that Zuma abused his power with this young woman who saw him as a leader, an elder to be respected, and someone to whom she owed total allegiance; she was not in a position to refuse his advances. She may not have been physically fighting him off, but this does not mean she was not forced against her will.

Then last week it was revealed that he is the father of a newborn extramarital child, the mother of whom is the daughter of one of his colleagues. And the revelations keep coming. So, obviously, there are many issues for discussion!

Respecting the fact that I am not a South African, nor a Zulu, I start from the position that there is nothing inherently morally wrong with polygamy, and subsequently wish to withhold moral judgment. Capital punishment is still legal in the United States, and I find this a significantly more immoral practice than polygamy, for instance. Polygamy is practiced all over the world and is at the end of the day just another family model, one that has functioned for time eternal. Where I feel I can extend judgment is in the fact that these unions tend to happen in places where women are oppressed and gender inequality is extreme. So, the extent to which women wish to engage in these unions is constrained by social context and the idea of choice must be critically understood. I venture that women tolerate this situations in part because there is no other model open to them.

My gravest concern lies around my area of research: HIV/AIDS. Zuma is a bad leader in this respect because he preaches one set of behaviors (condom use, faithfulness, abstinence) but then engages in others—a pregnancy outside wedlock is a) obviously a case of unprotected sex and b) an act of infidelity. In a country where young people are taught to emulate their elected leaders, it is dangerously irresponsible for Zuma to engage in such risky practices. He undermines his own credibility in acting this way. I heard a sound bite of Zuma speaking in Davos at the World Economic Forum last week, saying that polygamy is congruent with respecting women’s rights, a point on which I agree in principle I suppose (but life is often too messy for black-and-white principles!), but I do not necessarily think Zuma respects women’s rights…

I agree with most South African officials who have decided to drop the focus on single partnerships because this simply isn’t practical in South Africa or elsewhere. Instead they elect to focus on condom use. This is the best approach, in my opinion, until structural conditions change such that people value their own lives and have a less bleak future to look forward to. However, we can still judge Zuma on at least two fronts: 1) breaking his own marital bonds, sworn in marriage ceremonies, and 2) engaging in practices that literally risk lives. The third big one is, of course, the extent to which he claims his culture’s tolerance of polygamy is a disguise for oppressing women. I don’t feel comfortable touching the last topic because I don’t know how to do so without being a cultural imperialist or without at least engaging in a deep dialogue with a Zulu. So I’ll leave that to the Zulus to sort out.

I hope this posting sounds balanced and fair and that I’ve provided some background on this contentious topic. I understand from my parents that Zuma has got some international press lately, so I hope this posting is timely as well.

Incidentally, I actually SAW Zuma yesterday afternoon when he drove past Declan and I on the way to make his state of the nation address at the opening of parliament. He did look stressed!

Cheers,
Todd

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Nature's Valley

Hello friends. I have just returned from lovely long weekend in a little slice of paradise called Nature’s Valley. I visited with my housemate Emma whose family has rented a house in the valley for a month while her brother and his family are visiting from Australia. Nature’s Valley is a residential community set within the Tsitsikamma Forest along the South Africa’s famed Garden Route. The area offers lush vegetation of the jungle variety, with vines creeping all about. The weather was hot, the sun shined constantly, meaning I was in my perfect zone.

The place is exquisitely beautiful because the community of 300 homes sits on a huge lagoon that flows into the Indian Ocean. The lagoon is warm and calm, excellent for swimming, canoeing, fishing, and generally relaxing. I even awoke at 5am one morning to watch the sunrise while canoeing on the lagoon. The Indian Ocean here is ferocious, surrounded by craggy rocks and forested hills, rendering a kind of rugged beauty. Swimming in the ocean is seriously risky, which makes the lagoon setting so perfect. I developed a schedule of exploring in the mornings before the heat of the day, reading on the beach and swimming during the afternoon heat, running in the early evening, and just relaxing with the company at night.

The house in which we stayed, a huge six-bedroom spread, is built on stilts so that the main living area is in the tree canopy, a really cool experience. On several occasions I saw monkeys swinging through the trees. Emma’s parents had to chase a monkey out of the house one day, but not before he was able to abscond with an entire bunch of bananas.


Being South Africa, there are vineyards everywhere and we dined out at a fabulous tapas restaurant one day, sitting amongst the vines, with elephants wandering past in the distance (mostly I am sharing this because I want to show the photos :). It was a real treat.

It was also nice to be in an isolated place like Nature’s Valley where crime is not a constant concern. People sleep with doors open, kindly greet each other in the street, and there is a general absence of the rancor that dominates life in Cape Town. One only realizes the extent of security concerns, I suppose, when we are able to escape them. Window bars are such a regular feature of this country that houses seem naked without them.

Stay well friends. I can’t believe that I’ll be home six weeks from today!

Todd

Monday, February 1, 2010

Cape Town mon amour (and a day at the races)

Disclaimer: this post is a bit incongruous with others in that I indulge in many of the behaviors I find generally to be problematic! Apologies in advance; I’m only human.

Oh, my friends, did I attend a party on Saturday! South Africa’s Kentucky Derby-type event is called the J&B Met, and I was privileged to have a seat at the Khan’s table this year. As far as I can tell, the equestrian bonanza is really a reason for a lavish party where all possible hedonistic pleasures are pursued. It is the social event of the year in Cape Town. The theme for this year’s party was In Full Color and I did my best to embody the spirit, though I paled in comparison to others (enjoy the photos).

The event was particularly buzz-worthy this year because one of the horses, Pocket Power, was going for his record-breaking fourth consecutive victory at this event. But, it was not to be. His sister, River Jetez, beat him!!! I must say that I loved the whole experience, including viewing the horses, which are magnificent creatures. And the teeny-tiny jockeys just make me chuckle. The stables are like a colony of little people.

We had the best seats in the house, being at the intersection of the promenade from the stables and the racecourse and were seated just above a walkway where we could enjoy the spectacle (being a Commonwealth country, hat-wearing is compulsory). And you all know how I feel about a hosted bar! Attached are pictures of various parts of the day, including one of me with my friends Austin and Cede.

In other news, I have really hit my Cape Town groove over the course of the past few weeks, and it has really felt like my home, versus a temporary destination. I love my neighborhood and its artsy, academic vibe. I like my house with its patio, hammock, and outdoor shower. I love the myriad Cape Town beaches as well as all the events, excitement, and entertainment the city provides. But mostly I love the people whom I am fortunate to call my friends. It’s great to feel so settled, and the fact that the sun shines bright and hot every single day makes it infinitely better! Oh…and the food…and the hiking…and my neighborhood pool…and the crafts…are all amazing.

I actually realized all of the above last week when held a Q & A session with a group of undergraduates from Penn State who had just arrived in Cape Town. They’re in South Africa on a study abroad experience sponsored by a Professor I know well; he asked me to hold an informal meet and greet with the students, to which I happily agreed, in part because I discovered South Africa seven years ago on a journey much like the sojourn these students are embarking upon. I realized afterward how glowingly I spoke of Cape Town and how much I appreciate this place. It’s not that it doesn’t have its very dark, unseemly dimensions, but there is great virtue in focusing on the positive—and I’m learning to hold the different pieces in balance and surrender to the irreconcilability of all these stark juxtapositions. I did my best to share these various pieces with the students, but couldn’t help infecting them with positivity.

Oddly, this recognition came as I was in the process of planning my exit strategy from South Africa. My project has moved at a very steady clip such that I’ll be wrapping up the South Africa-based pieces by the middle of March, returning to Seattle at the end of March. I briefly paused to consider if I want to leave the bounty that surrounds me, but I also believe in exiting the party (well, generally I try to avoid the party, but…) when the wave is cresting. I don’t see much point in hanging on to the bitter end. So, I’ve got two months to tidy up my dissertation research, spend time in the company of great people, and continue to explore. A dear friend will be here for a couple weeks in March, and I am so looking forward to sharing this place with someone from home because South Africa as a vacation destination is tough to beat on many levels.

So, I’ll close by wishing everyone my best from the sunny cape.

Cheers,
Todd

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Why Can't South Africa 'Develop'?

The leaders of South Africa would have us believe that it is the rising sun of the African continent, the phoenix emerging from the ashes of a decayed continent. I do not share this sentiment, though I do think there are millions of everyday miracles, successes, and acts of heroism in South Africa. And I think South Africans know the way; they just need to be enabled to define their own course. It’s a bit of a ‘two steps forward, one step back’ situation at the current moment. Here’s my take on why:

First, Colonialism and the history of Apartheid left the country gutted of it’s natural resources and left the overwhelming majority of the population in a state of grinding poverty. The Apartheid economy was possible and so successful because it was built on the backs of some of the poorest people in the world’s labor. Now the task is for the democratic government to care for all of these people with the same resources that previously cared for less than fifteen percent of the population. These people are difficult to integrate into a developmental agenda because they lack skills, knowledge, and education; the knock-on effect is that even where a progressive agenda exists, there aren’t human resources to fill the void.

Second, debt. Apartheid was very expensive, especially in its waning years. As the years went on and the international community began to isolate South Africa, the situation became increasingly untenable. Maintenance of the Apartheid state was so costly because so many resources had to be used to suppress popular uprisings and keep 30 million people in a state of perpetual imprisonment. To fund this social experiment, the government eventually resorted to that age-old source of blood money, the World Bank. By the time Apartheid finally fell in 1994, the government had an international debt of 25 billion American dollars. The Bank has refused to forgive this debt post-Apartheid even when confronted with the way the money had been used and abused, so to this day South Africans are servicing the debt on the money used to violently oppress them. The country has not even started to pay down the principle and the new social programs have required a quick infusion of cash, meaning more loans. And the cycle continues...

Third, economic restructuring. In essence, the South African government promotes growth above all other benchmarks. So long as the macroeconomic situation looks good, leaders and international lenders are happy. The problem is that the fruits of this growth—which is real and there is more money circulating—is held by a very, very small group of people. To achieve this growth, taxes were cut, the currency devalued, environmental standards relaxed, labor power suppressed, etc., meaning the protections for the very poorest have been eliminated while wealth creation continues at a steady clip. Hence the widening of inequality and the deepening of poverty.

This last point is important. As I have alluded to before, progress has a strictly economic tone, so other measures of progress—like education attainment, gender equity, (un)employment statistics, etc. are backgrounded in favor of strict monetary growth. South Africa is a brilliant cautionary tale that elucidates the disconnects between the promises and reality of a trickle-down theory. The theory has failed catastrophically in South Africa over the past fifteen years and the country has followed the international financial institutions’ instructions with great precision.

I share the above information because people often ask me, “What’s the problem? Why can’t the place develop?” First, we must ask how we measure ‘development’ and then look at the big picture. I am always torn between thinking the situation is quite complex and the sense that really the problem is quite simple, with the latter usually dominating my thinking. There is a way out of this but it requires a paradigm shift the likes of which are not likely to occur anytime soon.

A fun blog posting next time, I promise.

My best,
T

Friday, January 22, 2010

The race card

The above phrase is one I never ever use because it presumes that race and ethnicity are some sort of chip in a high stakes card game, rather than very real (though anthropogenic) forces that forcefully shape human beings’ lives and experiences. Yet I hear the phrase tossed about all the time here in South Africa; whenever a problematic social issue is brought to the fore, people of all stripes will jump to an explanation of racism when responding to their detractors. Beyond the fact that racism is entrenched and pervasive, I think this impulse reflects many other things, including attempts to obscure the real issue under scrutiny. Social issues in South Africa are of such a staggering magnitude that no one seems able offer a tenable (palatable to those in power?) solution; tossing a claim of racism back into your opponents face when threatened is an quick way to wiggle out of the controversy. For instance, recently we had a problem at our house whereby some neighbors were making excessive noise in the street in the early morning hours. Emma, who is white, asked them, who are black, to stop the racket or at least tone it down. They immediately and unequivocally accused her of being racist. Save the fact that she could drag her black fiancĂ© out of the house to offer evidence to the contrary, in the moment she was at a total loss. The issue was a compelling one for me because it mirrored the same discourse I have been observing in the political arena. When we discussed it later having had time to reflect on the situation, Emma said she felt their response meant, “Don’t think you can tell me what to do, white woman.”

Similarly, a vicious fight is currently occurring between the African National Congress (ANC) and the South African Communist Party (SACP), the latter composed of many white and colored people unlike the ANC. When a person’s leadership is criticized on either side, racism is blamed versus examining the veracity of the claim. Meanwhile, the topics of redistribution and progress get sidelined. The same situation occurred when President Mbeki was criticized for his stance on AIDS; he flatly stated that his detractors were imperial Western racists, a claim that left his opposition in a very precarious position because the last thing they wanted was to be perceived as racist. Like anything, I seek to dig below the surface to explore the ‘real’ issue. And, to be clear, I know that racism exists and has power beyond my capacity to comprehend. I just think that in this context it is a purveyor of other unstated social issues simmering just below the surface.

The challenge with blame casting like this quick reliance on racism as a motivator is that it obscures the actual issue of inquiry. Here is what I feel that I know for sure: The way that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the body created to address the violence and injustice of Apartheid, operated left much to be desired. It was non-punitive, meaning people could confess their criminal acts without consequence. And it was voluntary so very few people ever got involved. This meant two key things: 1) those culpable for Apartheid’s grievous injustices were never punished, and 2) white people, particularly Afrikaners, were never forced to explicitly state that Apartheid was morally wrong. Add to this that white South Africans also managed to maintain ownership of industry and capital in South Africa such that their position within the country has only been enhanced (at the fall of Apartheid, the average white family was four times richer than the average black family; now that number is a factor of seven). So racial lines of difference matter very much but they must be framed appropriately as a consequence of economic choices and social restructuring post-Apartheid, particularly the choice to measure all social progress via market mechanisms.

In the meantime, the vision of progress in South Africa has become a strictly material one—each person out for themselves to make a buck and acquire possessions. The individual is the unit to be promoted and family structures have virtually vanished as people are continually fleeced of the means of survival. This is a consequence, I believe, of the influence of Western policies and the World Bank’s growth strategies for the country. The black population has taken on this agenda uncritically, which then infuriates the white population, both on principle and because there is the entrenched desire to not see black people well off. There is also a small but growing black bourgeoisie that is very visible, which represents a real challenge for the white population.

Ultimately, what I am saying is that the issue of race was never actually meaningfully addressed, particularly how race is a purveyor for all sorts of other social maladies like economic injustice, political disenfranchisement, etc. Because of this there is still no recognition of the fact that black people are poor due to structural conditions, not because of some sort of endemic inferiority. Now important matters of race have just become an easy fallback counter-claim in a country where there are no easy solutions. The choice to always invoke racism channels the fact that the race issue has never effectively been addressed and there has been very little healing post-Apartheid. In some senses, I believe that the gulfs dividing people are wider today than ever before. Racial disparities and attendant structural violence need to be addressed but to do so requires changing the system in a fundamental way, which those in power (black, white, colored, Indian, whomever) are strikingly unwilling, or feel paralyzed, to pursue. Until race is seen in it’s totality as a contextual social factor, I think its current use only serves to eclipse real issues at hand.